Supreme Court refuses to block Trump's bump stocks ban over Thomas and Gorsuch's dissents.
On Friday, the Supreme Court refused to block the Trump administration’s ban on bump stocks, which allow semi-automatic weapons to fire in rapid succession like a machine gun. Only Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch publicly dissented from the court’s decision, which means that bump stocks are now officially illegal in the entire United States. The perpetrator of the 2017 Las Vegas shooting—the worst in American history, in which 58 people were killed and 400 injured by gunfire—employed a bump stock. He used 13 rifles outfitted with bump stocks to fire 1,049 rounds in just 10 minutes. In November 2018, the Trump administration announced that it would issue a new regulation interpreting a federal machine gun ban to encompass bump stocks. The rule required owners of these devices to surrender or destroy them. No bump stocks would be grandfathered in, and anyone who continued to own the device after March 26, 2019, would be committing a federal felony. Gun rights groups quickly filed suit, alleging, among other things, that the federal statute prohibiting machine guns could not be plausibly read to cover bump stocks, as well. A federal district court ruled against the plaintiffs in February, and on Monday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit affirmed that decision by a 2–1 vote. The majority held that the federal “machine gun” ban is genuinely ambiguous, requiring courts to defer to executive branch’s interpretation of the law. (This principle is known as Chevron deference.) The dispute revolves around a provision of the statute that mandates a weapon cannot fire more than one shot “by a single function of the trigger.” A bump stock harnesses a rifle’s recoil energy to make the trigger reengage repeatedly once the shooter has pulled the trigger once. If the plaintiffs are correct, then bump stocks do not fall under the federal statute, because the trigger itself reengages with each shot. If the government is correct, bump stocks can be banned, because the shooter need only pull the trigger once to fire multiple rounds. Applying Chevron deference, the D.C. Circuit found that the government’s interpretation is perfectly reasonable and thus upheld the new rule. The plaintiffs plan to appeal that decision, but with Friday’s ruling, the Supreme Court declined to keep the ban on hold as they do so—a likely indication that a majority of the court does not believe the rule is unlawful. There are two possible reasons why Thomas and Gorsuch may have dissented. First, there is a chance the two justices believe the rule violates the Second Amendment; both are gun rights extremists, and Thomas has written that any “types of firearms commonly used for a lawful purpose” may not be constitutionally outlawed. Second, Thomas and Gorsuch may be irritated that the D.C. Circuit upheld the rule by applying Chevron deference. Both justices publicly oppose this doctrine, which they recently decried as “letting an interested party [an executive branch agency] … dictate an inferior interpretation of the law that may be more the product of politics than a scrupulous reading of the statute.” Thomas and Gorsuch would prefer that a court “buckles down to its job of saying what the law is” without deferring to the government’s reading of an ambiguous measure. By deferring to the Trump administration’s view of the federal machine gun ban, the D.C. Circuit surely rankled both justices. Regardless of the dissenters’ views, it’s apparent that there is little appetite by a majority of the court to protect a device that aided a recent, horrific, and notorious massacre. Chief Justice John Roberts, Justice Samuel Alito, and Justice Brett Kavanaugh do not seem eager to use this case to bolster the Second Amendment or curtail Chevron deference. And so hundreds of thousands of gun owners will now need to dispose of their bump stocks—or become federal criminals.Popular in News & Politics
Before the new rule, Americans owned about 520,000 bump stocks, which were legal in most of the country. Perhaps these justices believe that bump stocks are “commonly used for lawful purposes” and therefore protected by the Second Amendment.
相关推荐
-
A global problem is preventing the wars in Ukraine and Gaza from coming to an end.
-
兴农评丨开列“农科院食品”清单,整治李鬼
-
天全县人社局组织干部职工观看爱国影片《烈火英雄》
-
'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for May 4
-
How much for Oasis tickets? Fans joke about splurging on reunion shows
-
浙江大学农业文化遗产研究中心主任叶明儿:广东要把农业文化遗产纳入建设文化强省一部分
- 最近发表
-
- Wordle today: The answer and hints for August 29
- Nadal still the man to beat at Roland Garros: Alcaraz
- The best memes from Eurovision's first semi
- 61% of U.S. adults say Big Tech should restrict misinformation on social platforms
- Yoon, US Senate's armed service committee chief discuss alliance, N.K. threats
- 法官赵晓东——忠于法律 忠于事实
- 天全县人社局组织干部职工观看爱国影片《烈火英雄》
- Facebook says Trump may be back on the social network in January
- Google Search tries new tactics for limiting explicit deepfakes
- 《民俗走演》藏乡文化主题活动5月1日起正式开放运行
- 随机阅读
-
- AirPods Pro 3 and AirPods 4 may get revealed at the Apple September event
- FBI identifies suspect who sprayed Capitol officer with chemicals before he died.
- 'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for May 4
- 开设“特需窗口” 为老年人提供贴心服务
- Top 10 Most Significant Nvidia GPUs of All Time
- 一季度 我市实现外贸进出口总额2.64亿元
- Is US pressure on China, North Korea leading to new Cold War?
- 北京联合大学孙业红:“农遗”地区推进农文旅融合要防止城市公园化
- Freedom from Dissent
- Sesame Workshop marks Mental Health Awareness Month with emotional well
- Meta warns 1 million users of apps used to steal Facebook passwords
- 'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for May 4
- LG Display starts production of advanced OLED displays for gaming
- Nicolas Sarkozy anticipated the rise of Trump—and perhaps his downfall.
- 种类多到让你怀疑人生的新疆奶制品 | 南疆风物志⑨
- Amazon's first real NFL game was a major win for Prime subscriptions
- How 3D Game Rendering Works: Texturing
- Behold, 20 of the funniest YouTube videos ever, according to Reddit
- Free Comic Book Day is this weekend. Here are all the free comics you can grab.
- “渔业+”模式 为乡村振兴添动力
- 搜索
-
- 友情链接
-